Michelle Flaherty
Michelle Flaherty.1
Gender: Female
Known Relatives: Mary Flaherty (mom)
Harold Flaherty (Dad)
Cadence Flaherty (Sister)
Jim Levenstein (Husband)
Portrayed By: Alyson Hannigan
First Appearance: American Pie

Michelle Annabeth Flaherty first appears in American Pie in which Jim asks her to the prom as she pretends to be the only person in the school who has not seen the video of Jim prematurely ejaculating. After the prom Jim loses his virginity to Michelle who becomes aggressive and later leaves him to wake up alone, which amused him in the end rather than angering him.

She reappears in American Pie 2 where she pretends to be Jim's girlfriend so he won't have to have sex with Nadia until his penis has healed. She stages a break up in front of Nadia who later goes to the party with Jim. Jim realizes it is Michelle he wants, rather than Nadia. He goes to find Michelle at band camp, and gatecrashes the performance with a trombone, just like he did before, but with much more confidence and aggression, and romantically makes out with Michelle in front of a heart-warmed crowd.

In American Wedding, she and Jim have continued dating and she accepts Jim's offer of marriage at the beginning of the film. Michelle settles on a dress but it is only made by one particular dressmaker so Jim and his friends set out to find him for her. Michelle and Jim's plans are almost ruined when Stifler turns up to the engagement party although they had planned to keep him in the dark about it. After several hiccups including one with the flowers being killed which Stifler later fixes Michelle and Jim marry.

Band Camp revealed that after the events of American Wedding, Michelle became an annual macro at Tall Oaks Band Camp. However, she could not attend in the 2005 semester as she was heavily pregnant with Jim's baby. She requested that Noah, Jim's father, take her place, a request he took with much enthusiasm. In Naked Mile, Noah informs Erik Stifler that she had in fact given birth to a baby, to which he announced was a pride fuelling moment.

She appeared in American Reunion. Her son is now three years old.

American Pie Films vte
Main Films American PieAmerican Pie 2American WeddingAmerican Reunion
Spin-Offs Band CampThe Naked MileBeta HouseThe Book of Love
Characters Cadence Flaherty • Christopher Ostreicher • Chuck Sherman • Dwight Stifler • Erik Stifler • James Emanuel Levenstein • Jeanine Stifler • Victoria Lathum • Madison & Alexa • Matt Stifler • Michelle Flaherty • Mrs. Levenstein • Mrs. Myers • Kevin Myers • Nadia • Noah Levenstein • Paul Finch • Rob Shearson • Scott Stifler • Steve Stifler • Tracy Sterling

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.